• Welcome to the Pipe Organ Forum! This is a part of the open community Magle International Music Forums focused on pipe organs (also known as "church organs"), organists, organ music and related topics.

    This forum is intended to be a friendly place where technically advanced organists and beginners (or even non-organists) can feel comfortable having discussions and asking questions. We learn by reading and asking questions, and it is hoped that the beginners (or non-organists) will feel free to ask even the simplest questions, and that the more advanced organists will patiently answer these questions. On the other hand, we encourage complex, technical discussions of technique, music, organ-building, etc. The opinions and observations of a diverse group of people from around the world should prove to be interesting and stimulating to all of us.

    As pipe organ discussions can sometimes become lively, it should be pointed out that this is an open forum. Statements made here are the opinion of the poster, and not necessarily that of the forum itself, its administrator, or its moderators.

    In order to post a new topic - or reply to existing ones - you may join and become a member by clicking on Register New User. It's completely free and only requires a working email address (in order to confirm your registration - it will never be given away!). We strive to make this a friendly and informative forum for anyone interested in pipe organs and organ music.

    (Note: If you wish to link to and promote your own website please read this thread first.)

    Many kind regards
    smile.gif

    Frederik Magle
    Administrator

    Krummhorn
    Co-Administrator

Favorite completeBach Organ recordings

picketth

New member
Well this should liven things up.
What are your favorite complete Bach Organ music recordings?
Marie Claire Alain, Preston,Herrick,Koopmann, Rubsum,Bernard Foccroulle.. the list could go on?
I hope it does please, let me know your top 3 and why
Happy arguing!
Harry
 

Ghekorg7 (Ret)

Rear Admiral Appassionata (Ret)
1. Helmut Walcha
2. Marie Claire Alain
3. Wolfgang Stockmeier
4. Ton Coopman.

I also like many releases from Douglas Hollick and of course Peter Hurford.

Have fun !
Panos
 

Krummhorn

Administrator
Staff member
ADMINISTRATOR
1. Helmut Walcha
2. Peter Hurford

There are some things about Ton Koopman's playing style and registrations that I don't care for.
 

dll927

New member
Koopman tends to justify Albert Schweitzer's remark that Bach is played "altogether too fast". Do you suppose JSB himself played that fast? I doubt it.

M-C Alain has done about three different sets of Bach. She says she never listens to her recordings. I think she's missing something. Hurford is good, and Walcha goes back somewhat farther.

I still have a hard time with the notion that fast tempi equal virtuosity. Put that in a large cathedral with a long reverb time, and what do you have? A cacaphony of noise without hearing the 'voices' of the pieces. Which do you prefer?
 

Contratrombone64

Admiral of Fugues
Knud Vad (Danish)
Hans Fagius (Swedish)
Helmut Walch (German)

love all three of them equally for very different reasons.
 

Ghekorg7 (Ret)

Rear Admiral Appassionata (Ret)
Koopman tends to justify Albert Schweitzer's remark that Bach is played "altogether too fast". Do you suppose JSB himself played that fast? I doubt it.

M-C Alain has done about three different sets of Bach. She says she never listens to her recordings. I think she's missing something. Hurford is good, and Walcha goes back somewhat farther.

I still have a hard time with the notion that fast tempi equal virtuosity. Put that in a large cathedral with a long reverb time, and what do you have? A cacaphony of noise without hearing the 'voices' of the pieces. Which do you prefer?

Hi dll927 !

I posted elsewhere here some time back that my teacher taught me that Bach must be played slower, so all the voices can be heard clearly.
I was raised with this school and with Walcha's performances.

I love Marie_Claire..... just love her.... can't help it or explain it... he he

Ton.... he overdone it many times, but, there are some recordings that are just superb. His early TrioSonatas with Archiv, for example are perfect in everything.

Peter.... one of the best, but lately I got James Kirbe's total works of the grand master and I'm still listen to them (huge work), so far I'm very pleased and enjoy the resoult, but I don't have a final opinion yet about..

About Bach playin' fast..... our friend Marc here and David if I recall correctly... (Marc where are you??!!) reported that many contemporaries had writen about how fast and perfect he played.

I'm somewhere in the middle. I'm thinking that if someone then had used to listen to organ music played at about 69bpm and then someone came and played these pieces at 80 to 90, this would apear as fast !
Maybe I'm wrong, I don't know... You see at the time there aren't tempo markings on manuscripts so we do not know for shure the exact tempo Bach wanted.

There's another example with Widor. Almost all played his toccata fast and he (the creator) played it slow.....

So, I'm trying always to understand the inner meaning of the piece in question, how it feels and comes out as the first notes introduce themselves and then I decide the tempo. Playin at "breakin' neck speeds" (Lars' terminology) isn't by default a great virtuosity, sometimes may resemble to a circus performance !

Have fun anyway !
Panos
 

dll927

New member
Yes, I've read that Widor thought others played the toccata too fast. Supposedly there is a recording of Widor playing it, but he was close to 90 at the time, and surely no longer in his prime. This makes it sound agonizingly slow!!

The fact that no recordings exist of all those composers does leave things sort of up in the air. As for metronome markings, they are usually missing too. And one wonders if the markings in later editions were put there by the editors, rather than by the composers.

The late Sir George Solti and the Chicago Symphony did a complete cycle of Beethoven's symphonies for which the CD pamphlet makes quite a to-do about how Solti thought they should be played faster. Some of Beethoven's works had apparent metronome markings. Why did it take conductors 150 years to discover them???
 

Ghekorg7 (Ret)

Rear Admiral Appassionata (Ret)
Indeed, dll927

I met some composers in my life who could write a piece at a certain tempo and themselves couldn't play it that fast.... he he, so it was left to the performers to do it !
But anyway there was the metronome marking on the score, so no doubt of what the composer wants.
Editors do many.... "unwanted" or unapropriate stuff through the years.... and I believe their "legacy" went on to the record companies, hmmmm
 

Soubasse

New member
Messiaen was another, his own recordings of his works were notably slower than most other performances.

One can only imagine what JSB must have sounded like when he played. I'd also be curious to know how many of his compositions were performed first as an improvisation and then written down.

As for not knowing how fast he wanted them, we can never know if his own tempi were consistent either (I always have a good laugh when people refer to "Bach's metronome markings" - it's as inept as referring to "Bach's piano"). Without even a simple tempo marking such as "allegro" or "adagio" then one can reasonably assume that even tempi could be interpretive which, let's face it, they have been for centuries otherwise we wouldn't be having this discussion! :D
 
Last edited:

wljmrbill

Member
just to add a note to tempos...I think due to the action of many modern instruments..IN GENERAL much organ music is played to fast. I am sure do to the action of many of the old tracker instruments( and I have had some experience with the beasts) one could not have played them( compositions ) as fast as many muscians seem to now days. Just my 2 cents worth
 

Ghekorg7 (Ret)

Rear Admiral Appassionata (Ret)
Bill, this is a serious point. Yes.

Is like playin' the same piece on a soft synthesizer keyboard and on a full weighted 88 mother or even on a real piano one. The size of the keys is another factor I reccon...
 

Soubasse

New member
Good point - many of the early organ keyboards were similar to harpsichord keys in that they were shorter which is what lead to the "curled fingers" technique (or so it's assumed). Coupling manuals on older mechanical action organs will usually make the touch heavier - unless you're lucky enough to have a Barker lever (which JSB did not of course!)

What gets me about the Barker lever, particularly having experienced the one at St Sulpice, is just how damn well it works. Sure, it's noisy but who cares, when you can play with 4 or 5 manuals coupled and not notice, I'm not complaining! It would have been possible for Widor to have played his Toccata at breakneck speed and still retained the staccato markings ... interesting that he didn't.
 

Marc

New member
Other discussions about Bach organists (with integrals or not) can be found in this thread:

http://www.magle.dk/music-forums/10807-organ-music-j-s.html

Maybe they can be merged by a moderator/administrator?

About my favourite 'integrals': I would probably pick Ewald Kooiman (Coronata, OOP), Bram Beekman (Lindenberg, OOP) and Bernard Foccroulle (Ricercare). All three play a solid, rather straightfoward (which I like), nicely registrated Bach, with articulation and phrasing (not too much legato) that I like. They also seem to be aware of the various acoustics of the various places they play in. All three have picked really wonderful (restored) historic organs. In most cases I find these historic instruments more colourful than modern (neo-baroque) ones.
Very interesting integrals are also delivered IMO by f.i. Alessio Corti, George Ritchie, Marie-Claire Alain, Hans Fagius, Wolfgang Rübsam (especially his - now OOP - first integral), Helmut Walcha, Gerhard Weinberger, Lionel Rogg, Olivier Vernet, Christopher Herrick, Ton Koopman, Wolfgang Stockmeier, Knud Vad, Werner Jacob and and and .... all the ones I forgot to mention ;).
I find so much to enjoy in Bach's (organ) compositions that I'm only rarely really disappointed by an interpretation.

But I do have my preferences, of course.
 

Ghekorg7 (Ret)

Rear Admiral Appassionata (Ret)
How true brCD....

After all those years I still return to my H.Walcha's 15LP vinyl recordings..... One of the greatest ever... and of course Marie Claire Alain my all time inspiration.... so pure and instinct oriented organist. Lately I managed to gather all six parts of her video following Bach's path on Schnitger and Silbermann organs and made for myself a dvd and I'm watching and watching and the more I watch, the more I believe she knows exactly how Bach could have been playing his masterpieces, as of course knew Walcha the matter in deep... depth :)

PS. Rock-steady is a song of Bad Company !! LoL LoL :grin:
 

SamABristow

New member
Because of the variety of interpretations I find difficulty to decide. It depends on how I feel on that day. I have Helmut Walcha's, Marie Claire Alain's (3rd set), Peter Hurford's and Simon Preston's. They are all just as good as each other to me!
 
Top