My Search

[Twilightlord]

I've learned several musical instruments including the dulcimer, double bass, electric bass, a practice chanter and the tin whistle. My thing is, none really fit me. I've learned these fairly well, and on one instrument, the double bass, have managed to play at the symphony level. The reason I've started on several others is this. I'm looking for the one instrument to dedicate myself to. These are the points I'm trying to get from an instrument
~I want something classical and refined
~I also would enjoy if it were able to sound dark and melancholic at the same time as classical.
~I also would prefer it not be a woodwind or brass instrument.
~No percussion(excepting, of course things like pianos)

My original want was the pipe organ, but with the area I'm in, finding a teacher, or an organ for that matter, entails at least a two hour drive, if I could manage a teacher at all. No local churches actually employ the use of a pipe organ. So, I figured I'd use the magic of the internet to try and get the opinions of people more rounded in the subject than myself. I'm open to opinions on instruments, both new and old. Thanks guys

[rojo]

Well, as you know, there is a lot of transferring of knowledge when switching from one instrument to another. But to get to be really advanced on any instrument takes a lot of time. That said, if you have already progressed to the level of playing on the double bass as you state, why do you not want to continue with that instrument? From your list of points, it seems to fit perfectly..

[zlya]

Why do you need to dedicate yourself to one instrument? Why not just keep trying new ones and enjoying the experiences? I've learned six instruments, and I wouldn't dream of giving up any of them.

And who knows, maybe that way you will find one you can fall in love with. I really think there's no way for us to tell you what instrument will fit you, you just need to keep trying.

[Krummhorn]

There are some rather beautiful period instruments like the Recorder, or the Cromorne. Wondering why your adversion preference against woodwinds or brass.

If I had it to do all over again, I would have branched out way beyond the organ, although it has been refered to as the king of instruments. These days, I don't have the time to devote learning a new instrument. You are still young and have a whole life ahead of you - sieze every opportunity while you can ... !!