
Originally Posted by
Robert Newman
Contratrombones,
Thank you for your opinion. I won't reply with the same sarcasm.
The reason is rather simple. Music, you might learn, has both Form and Substance. You are deflected from liking this great musical performance of a virtually unknown Bach movement by matters of Form. But others love this music for its Substance. Which, after all, is more important.
Since Rosalyn Tureck was one of the great Bach interpreters of our time and a wonderfully sensitive and gifted keyboard player (both on piano and harpsichord) I'm sure the silent majority will have appreciated this post, just as a few will appreciate your own.
Regards
Robert