acc
Member
Re: Registration
I must confess that I never thought about starting Bach's St. Anne on a Grand-Jeu
- but now that you say it, it makes perfect sense!
Obviously, you're right about the "one plenum fits all" being a poor way of registering. I didn't mean to say that Bach or Buxtehude were insensitive to colours. It is a pretty safe guess to say that they did care about them - it's just that there is so little about it we actually know for sure (as opposed to the French repertoire). Do we know whether they even had clear-cut rules like the French?
Actually, that's one of the things I like so much about Harald Vogel's recordings of Buxtehude's organ works (published by MDG): the refinement in his search for colours is just amazing!
I must confess that I never thought about starting Bach's St. Anne on a Grand-Jeu
Obviously, you're right about the "one plenum fits all" being a poor way of registering. I didn't mean to say that Bach or Buxtehude were insensitive to colours. It is a pretty safe guess to say that they did care about them - it's just that there is so little about it we actually know for sure (as opposed to the French repertoire). Do we know whether they even had clear-cut rules like the French?
Actually, that's one of the things I like so much about Harald Vogel's recordings of Buxtehude's organ works (published by MDG): the refinement in his search for colours is just amazing!