Dorsetmike
Member
Having seen all three bands live on tour in UK back in the 60s/70s, I thought that Herman's Herd were much sharper/crisper (disciplined?) than the other two, it tends to show in most of their records to me, of the three though I think I prefer Basie, he usually seems to enjoy his music more, Ellington composed some great works.
Miller and Goodman I feel are in a slightly different category, other big bands like Billy May, and the Elgarts were more pure dance bands than jazz, Earl Bostic was for me moving in another direction which nobody else followed.
Not quite sure where to place the likes of Nelson Riddle and others often found backing various singers/crooners.
So it's difficult to choose a best, it all depends on personal preference.
Discuss!
Miller and Goodman I feel are in a slightly different category, other big bands like Billy May, and the Elgarts were more pure dance bands than jazz, Earl Bostic was for me moving in another direction which nobody else followed.
Not quite sure where to place the likes of Nelson Riddle and others often found backing various singers/crooners.
So it's difficult to choose a best, it all depends on personal preference.
Discuss!