View Full Version : just intonation

Mar-23-2004, 05:47
are pipe organs tuned justly or to
a 'strobotuner' or somesuch ? https://www.magle.dk/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/cheers444.gif

Mar-25-2004, 23:28
https://www.magle.dk/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gifMost Organ Tuners still tune by ear.....Tuning the "Temperament" Octave first....and either start with A 440
or C 440 and tune in 5th's & Octaves......Most Modern Piano Tuners use a Form of the Strobotuner (Yamaha Tuner etc) to tune.
Pipe Organ Tuning is an "art" like "voicing" and varies from Builder to Builder & Tuner to Tuner. Organ pipes are tuned Counting 'Beats' and sharpening/flattening as each type of pipe requires.Open Flue Pipes have Tuning slides and Wooden Pipes have slides or Stoppers. etc.Reed pipes have Wires to adjust the tounges...It's a Long Subject.
Piano Tuning is entirely different in that a Tuner can "stretch" the notes (strings) sharp or flat.
Using the Electronic tuners.....in both cases is ONLY mainly used for the Temperament Octave and then just to check other notes after final Tuning.
To tune an Instument (Piano or Organ) "Exactly" to one of these Tuners so that everything is "Perfect" does NOT work. The Human Ear does NOT like Perfect Sounds..Hence The "Chorus" effect....
It is a 1-2 Year Part of a 5 Year apprenticship to learn "Tuning" and is involved. Cheers https://www.magle.dk/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/cheers444.gif Pamadu/Paul.